The student news site of Pleasant Valley High School

Spartan Shield

The student news site of Pleasant Valley High School

Spartan Shield

The student news site of Pleasant Valley High School

Spartan Shield

The toxic culture of shopping hauls

Senior+Ava+Hahn+watches+a+Shein+haul+via+TikTok.+%0A
Sidney Brockmann
Senior Ava Hahn watches a Shein haul via TikTok.

Youtube headlines from influencers titled “$1000 haul” stand out to vulnerable consumers. In these hauls, these creators – typically women – share items they recently bought. Haulers talk about how excited they are about an item while justifying the purchase by explaining why they bought it and why it is worth the price.

Youtube, TikTok, Instagram and Snapchat are all flooded with hundreds of thousands of hauls. Although the intent of making hauls is typically just for fun, the toxicity of this trend is often overlooked.

The constant posting of clothing or item hauls promotes overspending and overconsumption. Oftentimes, these hauls present a problem as they are targeted towards younger audiences that lack a concept of money or personal finance education.

While watching, viewers often fail to recognize the hidden bias or marketing tactics involved in these “fun and entertaining” hauls. The benefits for influencers are endless as many get paid or are presented with free items or rewards when they promote a product in their video, though they do not always disclose this information.

When spending in this way is promoted, it becomes normalized. This makes people feel like they can find comfort in spending mass amounts of money at a time on goods that are almost always non-necessities. Hauls could be described as pushy advertising in a friendly way.

Senior Claire Horsfield enjoys hauls but also recognizes the pernicious aspects of them. “A lot of the time when you watch other people’s hauls, it makes you feel like you need what they have even if you can’t afford it,” Horsfield said. “It’s easy to feel insecure when you watch other people show off all the things they have that you don’t.”

It is no surprise targeted ads have already led to increased unnecessary spending, and hauls just make this problem worse. Not only are these videos encouraging more spending, but they are directed at people who would enjoy the videos the most. After watching a haul video, people who have fallen victim to the targeted ads visit the website of the advertised company and spend hundreds of dollars.

The increase in spending due to shopping hauls is just another effect of the digital age of advertising. Computer algorithms control what people spend their money on. Consumers that view hauls with full transparency regarding the motivation behind making them are on the safer side, while oblivious consumers are in danger of their wallets being robbed. Companies and influencers alike are taking advantage of oblivious consumers with hauls. 

Leave a Comment
Donate to Spartan Shield
$480
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Pleasant Valley High School in Bettendorf, Iowa. Your contribution will allow us to purchase needed equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
About the Contributor
Sidney Brockmann, Social Media Manager
Sidney Brockmann is the Social Media Manager of the Spartan Shield. As her first year writing for the Shield, Sidney is excited to be a member of the Spartan Shield. Throughout her years at Pleasant Valley High School, Sidney has taken up various positions in school activities. Sidney is an executive member of Spartan Assembly - Pleasant Valley’s student council where she plans meetings, organizes events, and discusses the power of leadership. In addition, Sidney is an officer of Future Business Leaders of America. Along with her leadership positions, Sidney has participated in choir and jazz choir all four years of high school, and enjoys playing tennis in the spring season. As a member of Girls Learn International club, Sidney discusses global and local issues with her peers. In her free time, Sidney spends time with her friends and family, getting coffee and ice cream. Additionally, Sidney loves listening to music, working out, and being outdoors. She is looking forward to writing for the Spartan Shield this year.
Donate to Spartan Shield
$480
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (0)

All Spartan Shield Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activate Search
The toxic culture of shopping hauls