Skip to Content
Gender disparities hold back women's sports from the local to international level
Categories:

Gender disparities hold back women’s sports from the local to international level

OPINION: Outdated stereotypes: Female Olympic athletes slammed for having ‘masculine’ bodies
OPINION: Outdated stereotypes: Female Olympic athletes slammed for having ‘masculine’ bodies

The 2024 Paris Olympics marked a substantial step forward for women in sports–the first year with an equal number of female and male athletes. Yet, many of these positive moments were overshadowed by controversy.

Many women took to social media to share how empowering and inspiring these athletes are to themselves and their daughters. On these olympian’s pages, like Ilona Maher’s, women comment thanking her for being positive, smart, strong, athletic and a role model. Others comment about the women and girls who will be inspired to try rugby because of her confidence.

Not only did these women break barriers and set records, but they embraced one another in sportsmanship and camaraderie, showing femininity in strength.

Most notably, U.S athletes Katie Ledecky (swimming) and Simone Biles (gymnastics) earned their 14th and 11th medals, respectively, the U.S. Women’s Basketball Team won their 8th straight gold medal and the U.S. women’s rugby 7’s team won the first medal for U.S. rugby. Despite being some of the most dominant women in their sports, they never fail to uplift other female athletes.

Photographers captured moments of Biles and fellow U.S. gymnastic gold medalist Jordan Chiles bowing to Brazilian gymnast Rebeca Andrade following her gold medal floor routine, and Ledecky and Ariarne Titmus holding their hands in the air  for one another after winning gold and silver medals.

The support between the Olympic women was one of many ways they shared powerful messages to the public. Coach Jane Wheeler appreciates the greater acceptance of strong, athletic women in comparison to the past and spreads messages of body positivity to the students she coaches.

“I have been coaching for 22 years and I’ve been an athlete for 30-some years, so I’ve seen the ideal [athlete body] evolve over my lifetime. I’m very happy that it has evolved in a more healthy way. For one, embracing strength in women mentally and physically. All body types can be amazing, and that it what I always talk about with my children and my team. I don’t worry what your bodies looks like, but what your body is capable of doing, and celebrating that our bodies are able to do such awesome things,” said Wheeler.

Women and athletes of similar age to Wheeler’s cross country runners have taken note of Maher’s impact on body positivity in women’s sports.

Maher has shared empowering messages to women and girls in sports, especially sports perceived as masculine. After being regarded as masculine due to her strength and size, Maher shares ‘feminine’ content, like makeup application and showing off her favorite dresses, displaying how she can be both feminine and a force on the field.

Rower Sophia Foad feels her team is an example of what Maher promotes. Foad appreciates being surrounded by athletes who want to be strong, fuel themselves and appreciate what their body can do rather than what it looks like. This positive environment was helpful as she made the transition from cross country to rowing. “When I first switched from cross country to rowing, I thought I don’t ever want to get that big. But when surrounded by people who have a good relationship with their body and food and what they need to fuel them, it’s a much more positive atmosphere and much more healthy atmosphere,” Foad expressed.

However, the perception of strong women as masculine does not stop at rugby players like Maher. At the 2023 Boxing World Championships, gold and bronze medalists Lin Yu-Ting (China) and Imane Khelif (Algeria) were stripped of their medals because they did not pass an IBA gender eligibility test. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) believes this test is not credible.

This test is especially harmful as Khelif is a woman and has been a woman her whole life in Algeria where being transgender is illegal.

In Paris, Khelif proved dominant, winning the gold medal for Algeria, but continued to face sexist and racist comments on social media and via news outlets justifying her abilities by anything other than her talent and hard work. Former President Donald Trump even commented that the two boxers were men who transitioned to being women, despite the falsehood of such a statement. The lies spread by Trump, news outlets, and social media users accumulated into widespread false information, and displayed the negative perception of women’s bodies in the media.

Athlete Gabi Ragins, who took second place in discus at the Iowa high school state track meet, finds these comments frustrating. “People who don’t understand athletics would like to judge people’s body types, when athletes train their body for one purpose and that’s to perform,” expressed Ragins.

This especially hits home for Ragins as she doesn’t fit the stereotypical mold of a thrower. Ragins felt empowered seeing an Olympic throwing athlete competing with a similar body type to her. “The woman who won gold for discus has a body type not stereotypical for a thrower. She transitioned from being a dancer. Her body type isn’t what you’d imagine from a stereotypical thrower. She’s very lean, has a six pack, looks like a female bodybuilder. It’s nice to see someone has a more similar body type to me,” added Ragins.

The constant attacks towards women in sports reveal patriarchal issues in how society views femininity. Athletes like Biles, Ledecky, Andrade and Maher show that strength is feminine and femininity includes all body types. Stereotyping women to weakness and top female athletes to masculinity is an outdated concept. There are women of all body types performing at the highest level of their sports, and they are strong, feminine women.

Barstool sports turn from promoting school spirit to cyberbullying
Barstool sports turn from promoting school spirit to cyberbullying

School rivalries began as a way to create a competitive atmosphere and promote school spirit, but have transitioned to cyberbullying on Barstool accounts. Almost every school in the country has a Barstool Twitter account affiliated with Barstool Sports to support student athletes and highlight success.

Originally created by Dave Portney, Barstool accounts are run by an anonymous student who is in charge of covering information regarding the school’s sports teams. Unlike other school social media accounts, Barstool is not directly affiliated with the school, making it extremely difficult to shut down.

Barstool accounts have been undoubtedly popular for creating excitement for games and encouraging school spirit. “Barstool in the sports world, especially football, is huge. It’s a way to get in the other team’s head and creates rivalry on the field. This year especially v.s. Bettendorf the game felt personal,” said senior football player Ben Birkel.

Although Barstool accounts report on their sports teams’ current success, they have begun to target their competitors’ athletes. Oftentimes, the trash talk shared has no relation to the sport and focuses solely on an athlete’s personal life. Accounts will scour social media for any embarrassing pictures or videos of an athlete or their family members and post them with demeaning captions.

These humiliating posts not only tarnish the image of the individual but also mar their digital footprint. A clean digital footprint is critical for obtaining job opportunities, extracurriculars and remaining in good standing at home and school. By exposing private information, Barstool sports damage an athlete’s reputation in their community and home.

Unfortunately, news spreads fast when Barstool posts are made and many students and parents tune in. “I think Barstool is definitely the talk of the town when something big is posted, everyone is talking about who got posted and what it was. It can be a big deal to be posted considering how many people can see,” said Pleasant Valley senior.

Additionally, Barstools often forget to comment on women’s sports. At PV, women’s sports are extremely successful, yet there isn’t one post congratulating the many women’s state championship titles. Within the past year, no posts supporting Pleasant Valley women’s sports have been made. In fact, the only post involving women is a retweet from over a year ago stating, “REMINDER: no females in the first 3 rows #youguyssuck”.

Oftentimes viewers end up being pleasantly surprised with how entertaining women’s sports are. “I think a lot of women’s sports are more enjoyable to watch. Everyone goes to the boy’s games because of all the hype. I wish the students would actually come to our games because they are fun to watch and we win. We don’t get any support for our games,” said senior and Basketball state champion Reagan Pagniano.

The administration has expressed its concerns with the controversial barstool account. The school prides itself in having a respectful, spirited student body. When tweets are blasted including slurs and derogatory comments, it reflects poorly on the entire student body. Not only is this behavior unfair to students who display positive qualities, but it also makes the school look less inviting and out of control.

Schools that truly believe in their sports programs don’t need to tear down their competitors’ athletes. Confidence in their abilities and sportsmanship should speak for itself. Barstool accounts give bullies a way to hide behind anonymity while pretending to support their school. Barstool is not an excuse to forget about morals and it’s time for students to understand that being a good person should matter more than the outcome of any game.

Students don’t give girl’s basketball a chance: How gender stereotypes impact student recreation

Girls sports at Pleasant Valley have been thriving over the last two years, proving time and again that PV is a competitive threat at the state level. However, while the girls basketball team has been looking strong once again this year, the student section has consistently shown the opposite.

Attending basketball games is an opportunity for many students to hangout with friends. While the boys team regularly has rows of students cheering, the girls are fortunate if most of the frontline shows up.

Other than a few students and parents, the bleachers feature an empty space where students are supposed to be. “We really don’t have a student section most times at our games. I think the few times we have had one it’s only been two or three rows of people,” said varsity basketball player Kaylee Mowen.

Unfortunately, this lack of support seems to stem from a deep-rooted stereotype against girls sports in general. “I think people just have an automatic bias that boys sports are better than girls sports and don’t really care to come watch. I think if people came to some of our good games they would see that they’re just as fun as boys’ games,” added Mowen.

Despite the assumption that girls games are lackluster, those that do attend girls games have no trouble finding them exciting and entertaining.

As a regular at the girls games, Bria Martell shared her experiences when attending., “I mainly go to the girls basketball games because they are fun to watch since the team is very skilled,” Martell noted.

It’s important to note that the Pleasant Valley girls basketball team were the Class 5A state champions in 2023, and with a 7-1 record so far for games against class 5A teams this season, the girls pose a significant threat to do damage at the State Tournament once again.

While many are aware of the team’s success, there is still negligence from students when it comes to showing up for their team. With big names such as Caitlin Clark breaking down barriers to viewership of women’s sports, it raises the question of when the mental shift will occur for students at PV.

Donate to Spartan Shield
$1000
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation will support the student journalists of Pleasant Valley High School in Bettendorf, Iowa. Your contribution will allow us to purchase needed equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

More to Discover
Donate to Spartan Shield
$1000
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal